Why Dividends Don’t Actually Make You Richer

Many investors and financial advisors focus on dividend-paying companies. At first glance, it sounds appealing. You receive regular income, no matter what the market does. But when you take a closer look, dividends may not be as valuable as they seem.

Dividends do not actually increase your investment’s value.

This may be surprising if you have heard the comparison between dividends and rental income. The idea is that you get paid just for holding the investment. But that comparison breaks down quickly when we look at how dividends actually work.

Prefer to watch the video?

What Is a Dividend?

A dividend is a payment from a company to its shareholders. These payments are usually made in cash and often come quarterly. The goal is to provide consistent income, even if the company’s stock price does not increase.

It sounds similar to owning a rental property. You get rent even if your house does not rise in value. But here is the key difference.

When a company pays a dividend, the company’s value goes down by the amount of that dividend. No new value is created. It is simply a transfer of money.

A Simple Example

Imagine a company is worth one million dollars. It decides to pay out fifty thousand dollars in dividends. Now, the company is worth nine hundred and fifty thousand dollars.

If you own ten percent of that company, your share is worth one hundred thousand dollars before the dividend. After the dividend is paid, your shares are worth ninety-five thousand dollars, and you have received five thousand dollars in cash. The total value is still one hundred thousand dollars.

The dividend did not create any extra value. It just moved money from the company into your hands.

Why the Rental Property Comparison Fails

If you own a rental property worth one hundred thousand dollars and receive five thousand dollars in rent, you are now worth one hundred and five thousand dollars. Rent adds value. Dividends do not.

This is the critical difference. Dividends feel like income, but they are not extra income in the same way that rent is. You are not growing your wealth. You are simply moving it.

A Tax Perspective

Some investors prefer dividends because they provide income in retirement. But that income may come with more tax than necessary.

If you hold dividend-paying stocks in a non-registered account, the dividends are taxed. If you hold non-dividend stocks and sell shares when you need money, you may pay less tax. Capital gains are taxed more efficiently than dividend income.

You also get more control. If you need three thousand dollars, you can sell that exact amount of shares. If you get a five thousand dollar dividend, you may pay tax on money you do not even need.

Inside registered accounts like TFSAs or RRSPs, tax does not affect this decision. But outside of them, it can make a meaningful difference.

Final Thoughts

There is nothing wrong with owning dividend-paying stocks. Many strong companies offer dividends. But it is important to understand that dividends do not increase your wealth. They only move money from inside the company into your personal account.

The next time someone promotes a dividend strategy as a way to grow your wealth, pause for a moment. Make sure the recommendation aligns with your goals, your tax situation, and the full picture of your retirement plan.

If you need help planning out your retirement visit our website and book an appointment with us.

Click here to book a free consultation with our team.

Watch the full video breakdown here.

Marc Sabourin is a Winnipeg-based Financial Advisor and Retirement Specialist with Harbourfront Wealth Management. His specialty is working with pre-retirees and retirees who are looking for retirement, investment, & tax advice. 

Disclaimer: The views expressed are those of Marc Sabourin, Certified Financial Planner, and Investment Advisor, and not necessarily those of Harbourfront Wealth Management Inc., a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund

SUBSCRIBE TO GET WEEKLY UPDATES

Get expert retirement insights straight to your inbox

20 Retirement Tips

When entering retirement or having recently retired, these 20 tips should be considered. A thorough retirement plan will touch on all 20.

Drastically change the lookout of your retirement

Get your guide below

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name