Avoid Withdrawing Funds When Your Investments Are Down

When you transition from working life to retirement, everything changes, especially the way your investments and portfolio should be structured.

Most retirees focus on their savings, but fewer people think about how their retirement portfolio strategy needs to shift once they start making withdrawals. What worked during the accumulation years may not serve you well in retirement.

Here is why.

Prefer to watch the video?

Sequence of Returns Becomes Critical

Let’s say you have $100,000 invested and you’re still working. Over the next 10 years, you earn the following returns:

  • Year one: down 18 percent
  • Years two through nine: up 6 percent
  • Year ten: up 26 percent

Your ending value after 10 years is around $164,000.

Now flip the returns. In year one you gain 26 percent, then earn 6 percent for several years, and in the final year, you lose 18 percent. The result is the same: your portfolio still ends up around $164,000.

If you’re not contributing or withdrawing, the order of the returns doesn’t matter. But once you retire and start withdrawing money, everything changes.

Withdrawals and Bad Timing Can Hurt

Now imagine that same $100,000 portfolio, but this time you are retired and withdrawing $10,000 at the end of each year, adjusted upward by 3 percent for inflation.

In the first scenario where the portfolio drops 18 percent in year one, you run out of money after 10 years. Your balance is negative $10,000.

In the second scenario where the portfolio gains 26 percent in year one, you end up with more than $46,000 after the same 10-year period.

Same portfolio. Same average return. Very different result.

This is called sequence of returns risk, and it is one of the biggest reasons your retirement portfolio strategy must be different from your accumulation strategy.

A Smarter Way: The Bucketing Strategy

To reduce the risk of selling investments during down markets, consider using a bucketing strategy. This involves dividing your retirement savings into separate buckets based on time horizon and risk level.

For example:

Bucket one holds one to two years of safe, liquid cash for spending needs
Bucket two holds medium-term investments for income or stability
Bucket three holds long-term growth investments for the later stages of retirement

By drawing from stable buckets when markets are down, you protect your long-term investments and reduce the chances of depleting your portfolio early.

Final Thoughts

If your retirement portfolio looks the same as it did while you were working, it may be time for a review. Retirement brings new risks and new rules. A thoughtful strategy can help you protect what you have and make it last.

For a personalized look at how to structure your retirement income plan, visit our website and book an appointment with us.

Click here to book a free consultation with our team.

Watch the full video breakdown here.

Marc Sabourin is a Winnipeg-based Financial Advisor and Retirement Specialist with Harbourfront Wealth Management. His specialty is working with pre-retirees and retirees who are looking for retirement, investment, & tax advice. 

Disclaimer: The views expressed are those of Marc Sabourin, Certified Financial Planner, and Investment Advisor, and not necessarily those of Harbourfront Wealth Management Inc., a member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund

SUBSCRIBE TO GET WEEKLY UPDATES

Get expert retirement insights straight to your inbox

20 Retirement Tips

When entering retirement or having recently retired, these 20 tips should be considered. A thorough retirement plan will touch on all 20.

Drastically change the lookout of your retirement

Get your guide below

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name